Faithful Rebel: Writer Micha Boyett on Becoming a Mom, Trying to be a Superstar, and Being Found Worthy

bookLG-found2Yes, I start this interview with the phrase, “Welcome so much.” (I dare you to start a hashtag.) First attempts can be awkward but I can’t think of a better person to launch my new web series, “Lessons from a Faithful Rebel” than writer and friend Micha Boyett who e-mailed me two hours before our chat and said, “I’m going to try to fix my hair beforehand,
so we’ll see how that works out.”

Micha’s haunting, lyrical, and lucid new book officially comes out this week. It’s called Found: A Story of Questions, Grace, and Everyday Prayer (Worthy, April 2014). It’s a story about losing prayer her first year as a new mom in a new city and wondering what being a “good Christian mom” had to do with her hopes for ministry stardom. Anxiety, Depression, and a daily dose of “Frantic” threatened to steal her identity as God’s beloved. (Which leads me to ask in the interview, “What’s up with that? Why do women struggle so much with these internal voices?”)  But as someone without children, what most captured my attention was her earnest search for home and finding stability in something more than your address or job description.

Watch our twenty-minute chat below and scroll down to find out how you can snag a copy of Found for yourself.

Want a free copy of 
Found? I’m buying. Enter to win by answering the following question in the comments section: How are you making a home where you are these days? I’ll choose a winner on Monday, April, 7th. #you’rewelcomesomuch






How vulnerable is too vulnerable when you’re in charge?

6a0105362ee2fb970c0120a755ce8c970b-800wiIf I hear one more person quote Leonard Cohen’s “There’s a crack in everything; that’s how the light gets in” I think I’m going to lose it. It’s not that it’s not true. It’s just that there’s more to the story. There’s a big difference between having a crack that shows you’re human and cracking up to the point of breakdown. And after the last retreat I facilitated, I worried my hairline fracture had quickly become a fault line.

Vulnerability has become a pop-darling these days thanks to the work of Brené Brown and others like her who have tried to dust off its shameful stigma and hold it up as a vital practice for cultivating trustworthy leaders. (Brown calls vulnerability “the birthplace of innovation, creativity, and change.”) Many Christians have acknowledged the necessity of vulnerability thanks in large part to timeless works like Henri Nouwen’s The Wounded Healer, Parker Palmer’s A Hidden Wholeness, and Frederick Buechner’s Telling Secrets. Buechner has particularly harsh words for ministers who trade authenticity for anecdotes.

You could say I profess vulnerability for a living. I’m a writer of the Christian-memoir variety which comes with a nauseating wave of discernment about what and how much to share about my life. But so too do I facilitate retreats for faith leaders wondering the same thing; how can I minister openheartedly without my life being an open book? Put another way, how can I be “appropriately” vulnerable without feeling unsafe, untrusting, or unprofessional?

It was the first full retreat I had ever co-facilitated. Two seasoned facilitators, both decades older than I, joined me in leading thirty ministers from across the country and Canada looking to build relational trust in their congregations. While we spent most of our time in a large learning circle, we broke into smaller groups for more intimate sessions, like the soul story process.

The soul story process is an activity designed by Susan Banyas to encourage honest sharing and holy listening. Each person in the group gets five minutes, uninterrupted, to share a story from their soul. While they are sharing, the rest of the group is listening for an image that story elicits. It could be a literal image mentioned in the story or one that comes to the listener unannounced. Once the person is finished sharing, the rest of the group takes another five minutes to paint a picture – with watercolors so as not to encourage perfectionism – that they then give to the focus person. Interpretation of the image is discouraged so as not to subtly coerce the focus person but instead each person, one-by-one, offers his or her painting as a gift, explaining only that, “This is a painting of a child’s crib” or “This is barbed wire holding together a heart.”

For this particular soul story session we were to reflect on a time in our ministry when we felt lost, starved, cut off from the root that animates our calling. I decided to tell a recent story from my writing life in which differences had become divisions between me and a collaborator. It was, as Buechner would say, a real “flesh-and-blood account”, one that was still painfully unresolved and one that still ran circles in my mind on crazy-making days. Later, I wondered why I didn’t choose something else, something that I had a better handle on rather than something that was “manhandling” me.

 Vulnerability Lesson #1: Choose stories or anecdotes to share that you’ve processed first in private. You don’t have to have perfect clarity before sharing publicly but it helps if you’ve had time to examine it with a trusted confidant.

There was a break between the time when we reflected on the story and when we gathered in our small group to share. I wandered out to the back porch of the retreat center and sat in a rocking chair with my laptop propped open. I hadn’t checked e-mail since we arrived and thought I could do a quick clean-up of my inbox before the soul story process began. A recent comment on a blog post was waiting to unravel me.

Vulnerability Lesson #2: Protect your inner sanctuary from attack before sharing by entering a space of quietude.

 I wish I had spent our break in prayer, silence, or Scripture as I prepared to lead my small group to potentially painful places for us all. Instead, I was wiping away the angry tears that had begun welling in my eyes, fixated now on how I could respond to the comment after the session with grace and maybe even a little holy fire. When it was time to begin the process, I came back inside, welcomed each group member to the circle, and took a shaky breath.

It began well enough. Someone shared, and then another person shared, and I was beginning to relax into my chair as we moved from listening to painting to giving our images away like balloons to an unknown sky. We were halfway through the third person sharing when the door to our gathering space opened and one of the facilities managers walked in. “Erin, I need to talk to you.”

Vulnerability Lesson #3: Protect your outer sanctuary from interruption once you’ve begun sharing by drawing appropriate boundaries.

By God’s grace, I was able to say firmly but calmly, “I will need to talk to you in five or ten minutes.” For someone like me who is often a wuss-on-the-spot but a bear-in-the-aftermath, this was no small gift to find my words in the moment. I waited for the person sharing to finish, left the room, dealt with the issue at hand, and returned. Still, the confrontation left me even more rankled than ever and I hadn’t even shared my own story yet.

Vulnerability Lesson #4: If you feel emotionally unsafe when it’s time to share, you risk inviting harm to your own soul or even doing harm to others. Don’t be afraid to course-correct; you can always decide to share more later.

In the end, I didn’t have enough self-awareness to change direction and instead shared my story as planned. By the end of my allotted time, tears were fogging my eyes and doubts were clouding my thoughts. I wondered if it was hard for my group members to paint through the nagging questions they had about me. Who is this woman? So young? So naïve? So fragile? What does she know anyway about ministry, about life, about living openheartedly?

I was astounded by their responses. The pictures were dripping wet with compassion. Somehow they each saw through the fear and the anxiety and the anger in my story and made out the truth of my words. Even though I was sure I had crossed the line between a facilitator with an open heart and one who was just falling apart, in that moment, they became ministers to me.

It is a hard balance in ministry between being a leader who invites vulnerability and being a leader who is so vulnerable s/he needs constant consoling from those s/he serves. Jesus modeled the kind of vulnerability we’re all after; openhearted enough to be affected but surefooted enough to be effective. Very often, I need help in discerning how I’m holding this leadership paradox. When I later recounted my “misstep” with one of my co-facilitators, she said to me without a lick of pity, “Erin, I wouldn’t have done a thing different.”

When we risk leading with vulnerability, we risk leading from our wounds. To be sure, our wounds are unavoidable. Like shadows or cracks, we carry them with us wherever we go. But like shadows or cracks, they are not the whole story. The flesh is more substantial than the shadow. The vessel is more prominent than the crack. Our gifts are brighter than our wounds.

Whether in life or ministry, we lead openheartedly when we lead with our whole selves but so, too, do we become whole by turning toward the light.

Faithful Rebel: Songwriter Carrie Newcomer on A Permeable Life

Carrie_Newcomer_Before_and_After_guitar_case“When you live a permeable life, you’re making a deal with the universe that I will be here and I will be present and I will take in the world,” Carrie reflected with me over the phone last week. I say her name plainly but this is Carrie Newcomer, folk singer and songwriter, who on April 1st is officially releasing her fifteenth studio album, A Permeable Life, and – for the first time – a book of poems and essays with the same name to accompany it.

Songwriting, like a permeable life, requires the practice of attention, says Carrie, and the choice to show up as your true self in the world. Even after just a few moments of spotty cell coverage, me in my Durham office and Carrie in her home in the Indiana woods, it’s clear that this woman practices what she preaches. Her speaking voice is as kind and slow as her singing voice is deep and wise. I decide to count my conversation with her as my spiritual practice for the day. She’s that good for the soul.

I’m a fairly new fan to Newcomer’s music. I met her for the first time last August at our annual Habits of the Hearts for Healthy Congregations retreat with Parker Palmer where she shared her music with a group of over 100 clergy and faith leaders and shared her life in quiet conversations played out over mealtime. I remember asking her about dogs, and whether Rush and I should get a second one. I worried we couldn’t love another with the kind of teeth-clenching intensity we felt for our red-headed mutt Amelia. “Love is not like a pie where there are only so many pieces to go around,” she said. “With every dog, or every child, you just get more pie. There is always more love available to us.”

With that same bent toward simplicity, she set out to create her latest album. Her voice quickens for a brief moment as she divulges the collaborative process with producer Paul Mahern and a handful of talented musicians, many under thirty. “There is simplicity when you don’t know what else to do and then there is simplicity when you can play all sorts of notes and say all sorts of things but you don’t. It’s elegant, myself and all the musicians, it’s a very ego-less kind of playing.” These are true enough words for a musician as they are a writer or a preacher. Two kinds of simplicity – the one that comes out in your first draft, lazy in its pomp and wordiness, and the one that finds you on the other side of time. It’s after the throat-clearing quotes and meaningless jargon disappear that what you’ve been trying to say all along becomes clear.

I listen to Carrie’s music when I need to de-clutter my mind. I put her music on when I do yoga in the sun room; sometimes Amelia comes in and does a downward dog under the bridge of my downward dog and I collapse over the mystery. I put her music in my CD player when I’m driving to church on Sunday nights and mustering the courage of true self. Carrie is by no means a “Christian artist.” She says, “Theologically you get the eight crayon box in the Christian music world; theologically I’m the 48 crayon kind of girl. There are beautiful things than can be created with the 8 crayons but at the same time, there’s a hunger and longing for music and story and dance and art forms that lean into the spiritual, that is looking for new language.”

I ask Carrie about her spiritual heritage; I tell her I suspect she’s what I call  on this blog a “faithful rebel.” She grew up Methodist but her fury with the traditional church’s treatment of women led her to find spiritual community with the Quakers. Friends commented, “You make your life with sound and yet you go to a silent community!” She laughs as she’s telling me this, but then becomes serious. “We talk at the universe or God or the Light as Quakers would call it, but something really amazing happens when you are quiet long enough to hear.”

A_Permeable_Life_CoverIt’s hard to be quiet in a culture like ours where the impulse is to do more, be more, throw one more ball up in the air. Carrie challenges the assumption of “not enoughness” in her pie-life-philosophy and prophet-like-words in the new album and book (available for pre-order on her website). When we’re all scrambling to find a life of more, maybe the answer is to do less. “We expand time by actually being there,” Carrie tells me.

We’ve only been talking for forty minutes, but what she says is true; my breath is deeper than when we started.

What are you holding back?

Consider that most fear
is not fear of failure:
rather, it’s fear to live fully,
in full power.
- Clarissa Pinkola Estés


For a decade and a year, I’ve had the feeling that I’m holding something back.  I told a friend this over pasta salad at Parker & Otis and she said, “Maybe it’s because you’re an introvert.” This is one explanation. Another explanation is that I am afraid of something. This is the more likely explanation. I am afraid of showing up in church as my full, true, complicated self. I am afraid I am too much to handle.

I am afraid you won’t be able to handle me. You won’t know what to do when I say during the prayers of the people, “I am mad (and I have been mad since I was eight.)” You will want to comfort me, make it better, make the madness go away but what you don’t understand is the madness is a part of me. I wish you would ask “Tell me why you’re mad,” or “What does it feel like to be that mad?” or “Where does the madness live in your body?” Instead, I fear I’ve rendered you helpless, put you out, made you uncomfortable. I didn’t want to do that. I just wanted to be mad.

I am afraid I won’t be able to handle me. Silence is a romantic kind of thing. Sometimes it’s easier not speaking my voice. It’s easier not knowing if there are a few good souls who can hear my story and say it is theirs, too. It’s lonely to say in a small group “I am always finding and losing myself in marriage,” and to hear in response, “How old are you? You’ll learn to comprise.” It is as if I am a caricature of my generation rather than a real person. When I speak about who I am, what I love, and the questions I hold close, I risk feeling more alien than before I spoke. I can hardly bear the disappointment of finding out there is no echo for my longing here. I’m already mad enough.

I am afraid that God won’t be able to handle me. I’ve always believed that God can handle anything. I also believe that God loves what is holy, and if I could just decide to be more holy, more obedient, more intentional, I wouldn’t be such a mess. I would show up in prayer contrite not confused. I would show up on my blog confident not questioning. I would show up in worship controlled not abandoned. It’s not that I think God can’t handle me; it’s that I behave as if I can handle me without him. I wouldn’t want to make him mad.

To celebrate Women’s History Month, I’ll be co-leading a Talking Taboo workshop at Middle Collegiate Church in Manhattan on Sunday, March 16th from 4:00 – 5:30 p.m. Joining me are two contributors, the Reverend Jennifer Crumpton and Poet Aja Monet; together we will ask the question “What am I holding back?” and “How can I start showing up?” at church.

Because a holy life or a “wholly” life takes public practice, not private perfection. It starts with a decision to show up, then another to test that feeling in the quiet, and then another to speak your knowing out loud. It continues on like this with a lot of bumps and bruises as your complicated self gets tangled in my complicated self, but it always ends in a live encounter. And isn’t a live encounter the best any of us can hope for in church? That moment where the spirit of God breaks through the b.s. and we can say to the person beside us with awe, “That shit just got real”?

It only takes one person to show up as her full, true, and complicated self at church to make it a little bit safer for everyone else to do the same. The only thing holding us back is our fear, and fear can’t handle a love like ours. God’s love is too much.

Perfect love casteth out fear – 1 John 4:18

Sometimes I wish I were a dude

photo (32)This post is an excerpt from my piece in the booklet, Courageous Conversations (2013), edited by elizabeth mcmanus and published by RCWMS press. Search books on the RCWMS website to order ($5)

I’ve been trying to figure out how to say this for a while now. Maybe even for a year or three. Probably since I moved from California to a place called Durham where the women seemed more womenly and the men folk seemed more, well, khaki. I’ve been trying to figure out how to say this without sounding like the type of woman I loathe, without sounding ungrateful to mothers, sisters, and feminists everywhere, without looking the gift-God in the mouth.

Sometimes I wish I were a dude. More precisely, sometimes I wish I could act like a dude.

1.) Dudes aren’t expected to do as many dude things with one another. Oh, they might have a pancake breakfast once a month at the church but it’ll be on Saturday and they’ll cite wanting to spend more time with the wife as their reason for missing and some woman will surely end up giving them a pat on the back for being that sort of family man. Women’s bible study, on the other hands, meets every Thursday morning according to the bulletin. It wasn’t until a girlfriend recently shared aloud that she just “doesn’t do groups” that I thought to myself, “Really? You mean it’s okay for a woman to not hang out in packs? It’s okay for me to be kind of a loner? You mean that’s not just for cowboys and Jack Reacher?”

2.) Dudes tell it like it is (or at least how they think it is). This, in turn, frees me up to do the same. I can be competitive without offending and interrupt without clamoring and trust that no one’s analyzing my every move more than I because I am, afterall, a woman. It’s the emotional labor expected of being a woman that I find so awkward and unbecoming on me. A friend tells me her husband is lonely and would my husband be willing to call him up? Sure, I think. But why not just ask him? Why do I have to be responsible for my husband’s social calendar on top of my own? Another friend says she’s worried about a girlfriend of ours. Okay, I think. But what do you want me to do about it? Why do I have to sit here strategizing when we might as well just ask her? And who made it a woman’s job to anticipate the needs of others before they’ve even been named? Call me callous, uncaring, or unchristian but I don’t want this undercover job.

3.) Dudes drink beer at lunch. I can’t tell you how jealous I am of a standing date my husband has every Friday at Sam’s Quick Shop to grab a pint with a buddy who’s on lunch break. When I asked a girlfriend why we rarely drink together, she said she didn’t really like alcoholic all that much and, besides, there were those calories to account for. It’s no one’s fault really, a freak of context that I’ve found myself in a place where the lady drinkers are few and the wine lovers among them fewer. But I want the carelessness or carefreeness of dudes who don’t worry as much about growing guts and going out budgets. It helps, too, that they’re not worrying about making babies in their bellies, or eyeing their friends shrewdly when they pass on a French 75.

Hear me when I say I want to act like a dude not a man. Because, of course, I know that the dude is a caricature, no more an accurate picture of all of manhood than my one experience is of womanhood. I know, too, that no one is stopping me from acting not like a dude, but as an independent, straight-talking, “what the hell it’s noon” kind of woman. Perhaps it’s I who has all the hang ups about the expectations others have hung round my neck.

Sure, I’ve found a rare group of women or two where I can soar with more than four in the room. But who’s to say that a feminist has to love women’s groups? I’ve spoken up with close friends when I sensed there was a need going unnamed.  But who’s to say that a Christian has to be not just her sister’s keeper but every sister’s keeper? I’ve counted calories and dollars signs and decided I’d rather not fall asleep at 2pm today. But who’s to say that a woman can’t drink a tall one over a grilled cheese sandwich without being a lush?

And that’s just the thing. I don’t know who’s saying.

Only that I want a say.

Consider this teleconference good for your health

t1larg.juiceLast week, I came across this quote from Sister Joan Chittister: “Not only does what our churches, mosques, synagogues, and faith communities teach and do about women become the morality of the land — what they do not say or do on behalf of women condones what becomes the immorality of the land.” Is this not true? I’ve met more kindhearted pastors who don’t have much to say about women at all (other than we support ‘em) than I have the fork-tongued, slandering kind. Sin is an easy silence.

This month, I was joined by contributor Robyn Henderson-Espinoza in a teleconference with the Women’s Alliance for Theology, Ritual, and Ethics. You can find a link to the recording and notes from it by clicking here. Robyn talked about being a Queer Baptist seminarian who tattooed her body with memories of faith and doubt.  I shared how my sense of identity as a Christian without children has grown stronger as I’ve been able to say to others with increasing grace, “I am not the woman you had in mind.” Sometimes I have to say this to myself, too.

In just a few days (Wed, Feb 5, 1-2pm ET), there will be another teleconference with four more contributors talking about women’s ordination to the priesthood, the temptation of adultery, worldwide reproductive health, and the belief that broken bodies are Spirit-filled bodies. Sign up for the teleconference by clicking here.

Consider it a matter of health to register, your extra dose of Vitamin-W for our bone-drying deficiencies in women’s voices.

Why Using “He” in Worship Could Be Hurting More People Than You Think

showImageThis post was originally published on Q Ideas.

“Give me one moment while I have a conniption fit,” I cautioned Rush. We had been fine a few minutes earlier, talking about a worship service he was planning for his youth group. Our friend Will, who would be leading music with him, had just spent an hour picking and strumming and singing in our living room. I apologized to Rush for being a hermit and not coming out of the bedroom to say hello, but there was no bad blood between us. Not until he mentioned a particular song he was planning to sing.

Sunday worship is the hardest hour of my week. And it’s not because I’m an introvert who often sits alone. Nor is it because I have trouble hearing God in a service that relies so heavily on words, words, and more words. Sunday worship is the hardest hour of my week because it’s the one in which I show up begging to get a glimpse of God’s abundance and leave feeling a little less human. It’s the one where I worship a God who is always a he.

“You’re singing the jealous song?” I asked, actively working on my tone. Rush tells me my tone is often off-the-charts awful. I tell him maybe he’s tone deaf. Either way, I wanted to play nice with my partner.

“And that’s the song that says something like, ‘He loves like a hurricane and we bend like a tree under his wind and mercy?’”

By now Rush could tell something was festering because I was trying too hard and trying too hard was the telltale sign. Something did not fit.

Let me dispel your fears that I am looking to make God into my image. I am not. But I expect this happens to us, men and women alike, from time to time. We are, after all, talking about God, the God whose thoughts are not our thoughts, whose ways are not our ways (Is. 55:8.). No, I am looking to worship the God of reality, from whom the image of both male and female and everyone in between was patterned. Genesis assures us of this much. God is not some neutered, gender-less spirit in the sky. Rather, God is more than, higher than, fuller than our human thoughts and ways of gender. I’ve come to believe that we worship a gender-full God.

This belief makes worshiping such a God rather, well, complicated. While most mainline Protestants I come across agree with me that God is neither male nor female, the majority is unwilling to change the lyrics of modern-day music to reflect said reality. One former pastor assured me that I was free to change the lyrics myself, singing God for every he, God’s self for every himself. I told him this didn’t seem to be the point of worship considering the biblical mandate that we be of one mind and spirit (Phil 2:2.) Shouldn’t we at least be able to be of one lyric?

So, I asked Rush, kindly I thought, “What do you think about changing the lyrics of that song? To be honest, singing about a nameless he—even if it is meant to be Jesus—kind of reminds me of a domestic violence situation. I mean, we bend beneath his weight like a hurricane?” I thought about the recent statistics I’d read in which one in every four women is expected to experience domestic violence in her life time. Was it safe to assume one in every four women sitting in church might experience the same? Was it possible worship leaders did not know this, did not know one of these women?

To continue reading the article, head over to Q Ideas.